Astro A40 vs A50: Which Is Really Better?

Disclosure: I only recommend products I would use myself. This post may contain affiliate links and I may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you.

Among the top contenders in the gaming audio realm are the Astro A40 and A50 gaming headsets, both renowned for their exceptional sound quality and comfort. But how do these two titans of gaming audio stack up against each other?

In this article, we’ll dive deep into the intricate details of the Astro A40 vs. A50 headsets, comparing their features, performance, and value for money. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of which headset suits your gaming preferences and budget, ensuring that you’re well-equipped to take on any virtual battlefield or immersive gaming world that comes your way. Let’s embark on this sonic showdown and discover which Astro headset reigns supreme in the gaming audio arena.

astro a40 vs a50

Also, check out our post on the comparison between Astro A30 and A50

Astro A40 vs A50 Gaming Headsets Comparison

Astro Gaming is renowned for delivering premium audio experiences, and their A40 and A50 headsets are no exception. In this quick comparison, we dive into the key differences between the two, helping you decide which Astro headset best suits your gaming needs.

Astro A40:

  • Wired headset with exceptional audio quality.
  • Highly customizable with mod kits for personalized style.
  • Ideal for e-sports and competitive gaming with precise sound positioning.
  • MixAmp compatibility for audio control.

Astro A50:

  • Wireless freedom with high-quality audio.
  • Dolby Audio for immersive 3D sound.
  • Convenient docking station for charging and storage.
  • Ideal for gamers who prioritize wireless convenience and immersive audio.

Your choice between the Astro A40 and A50 depends on whether you prioritize wired precision and customization or wireless freedom with immersive audio.

Astro Gaming A40 TR vs Astro Gaming A50 Specs

Specs

Astro A40 TR

Astro A50

Drivers

Dynamic, 40 mm sound driver

40 mm Neodymium magnet

Frequency response

20Hz – 20,000Hz

20Hz – 20,000Hz

Connection

3.5 mm mini-stereo and PC splitter

USB Micro-B (2.0), AUX in/Mic out (3.5 mm)

Microphone

6.0 mm uni-directional

6.0 mm uni-directional, voice isolating

Pickup

Unidirectional

Unidirectional

Weight

369 g

370 g (without cable)

Price

$129.99

$279.99

Price

Astro A40 Pros and Cons

a40

PROS:

  • Exceptional Audio Quality: The Astro A40 delivers high-quality audio, allowing you to hear every detail in your games.
  • Customizability: These headsets are highly customizable, with mod kits available for personalized style and function.
  • Precise Sound Positioning: Ideal for e-sports and competitive gaming, the A40 provides precise sound positioning, giving you an edge in gameplay.
  • MixAmp Compatibility: You can pair the A40 with Astro’s MixAmp for advanced audio control and customization.

CONS:

  • Wired Connectivity: Being a wired headset may limit your freedom of movement compared to wireless alternatives.
  • Price: The A40, while offering excellent quality, is on the pricier side of gaming headsets.
  • External MixAmp Required: To access its full range of features, you need to purchase the MixAmp separately, which adds to the overall cost.
  • Limited Noise Isolation: The A40 doesn’t offer the same level of noise isolation as some other headsets, potentially allowing external sounds to interfere with your gaming experience.

Sale
Astro A40
Astro A40
$229.99 −$50.00 $179.99

Astro A50 Pros and Cons

Astro A40 vs A50: Which Is Really Better?

PROS:

  1. Wireless Freedom: The Astro A50 provides wireless convenience, eliminating the need for tangled cables and offering greater mobility.
  2. Immersive 3D Sound: With Dolby Audio support, the A50 delivers immersive 3D sound, enhancing your gaming experience.
  3. Convenient Docking Station: The included docking station not only charges the headset but also provides a handy storage solution.
  4. Comfortable Fit: The A50 is known for its comfortable design, allowing for extended gaming sessions without discomfort.

CONS:

  1. Higher Price: The A50 typically comes at a higher price point compared to wired alternatives, making it a more significant investment.
  2. Battery Dependency: As a wireless headset, the A50 relies on a rechargeable battery, which means you’ll need to manage charging to avoid interruptions.
  3. Limited Compatibility: While compatible with multiple platforms, the A50 may require additional accessories or configurations for certain devices.

Sale
Astro A50
Astro A50
$299.99 −$57.32 $242.67

Main Differences Between the Astro A40 vs Astro A50

  1. Wired vs. Wireless: The Astro A40 is a wired headset, while the Astro A50 offers wireless convenience.
  2. Customizability vs. Immersion: The A40 is highly customizable with mod kits, ideal for competitive gaming. The A50 prioritizes immersive 3D sound and wireless freedom.
  3. Price vs. Convenience: The A40 tends to be more budget-friendly, while the A50 comes at a higher price point due to its wireless features and enhanced audio experience.
  4. MixAmp vs. Docking Station: The A40 can be paired with a MixAmp for audio control, whereas the A50 includes a docking station for charging and storage.

Comparing Features of Astro A40 and A50 Headsets

Let’s Explore the distinctions between the Astro A40 and A50 gaming headsets.

Common sound quality characteristics:

  • Both the Astro A40 and Astro A50 feature 40mm drivers and share an identical frequency response range, spanning from 20 Hz to 20 kHz.
  • In terms of sound quality, the A40 and A50 are nearly identical, offering excellent audio with the ability to reproduce both high and low-frequency tones effectively.
  • Both headsets support Dolby Atmos, providing 7.1 surround sound for an immersive listening experience.
  • Surround sound is valuable for competitive gaming, aiding in precise enemy location detection, and enhancing immersion in music and movies with dynamic audio.

Advantages of Astro A50:

  • The Astro A50 has a built-in MixAmp Pro within its charging base, offering remote control capabilities.
  • In contrast, the Astro A40 requires a separate purchase of the MixAmp Pro for remote headset management.

buil-in-MixAmp

Sale
Astro A50
Astro A50
$299.99 −$57.32 $242.67

Astro A40 MixAmp Pro TR

The Astro A40 comes with an external Gaming MixAmp Pro TR, tailored to the requirements of dedicated gamers and streamers who require advanced audio control. This external MixAmp offers precise adjustment of sound volume, customization of EQ presets, and the ability to fine-tune the balance between in-game audio and voice communication, providing a comprehensive audio management solution..

MixAmp-Pro-TR-Astro-A40

Sale
Astro A40
Astro A40
$229.99 −$50.00 $179.99

Design and Build: Astro A40 and A50

Astro A40:

  1. Futuristic Look: The Astro A40 boasts a futuristic design that seamlessly complements stylish PC builds and console setups, exuding a premium appearance.
  2. Pivot Ear Cups: The A40 features pivot ear cups, allowing them to rest on your shoulders when not in use.
  3. Long-Term Comfort: Designed for extended gaming sessions, the A40 incorporates comfortable foam padding and fabric ear cups, preventing issues like sweaty ears and discomfort. Users can wear them for up to 10-11 hours without irritation.
  4. Adjustable Sliders: Adjustable sliders on the A40 ensure a comfortable fit for various head sizes, including larger heads.
  5. Clamping Power: The ear cup clamping force of the A40 may initially be tight but gradually loosens up after a few hours of use, enhancing comfort.

You can find out the detailed video review of Astro A40 here:

VIDEO
ASTRO Gaming A40 TR X Edition Headset Black And Red Mod Kit Ready Design Unboxing
Sale
Astro A40
Astro A40
$229.99 −$50.00 $179.99

Astro A50:

  1. Wireless Convenience: The Astro A50 offers wireless freedom, eliminating the need for cables and enhancing mobility.
  2. Docking Station: It includes a docking station for charging and storage, providing added convenience.
  3. Dolby Atmos Support: The A50 supports Dolby Atmos, delivering immersive 3D sound.
  4. Comfortable Fit: The A50 allows for extended gaming sessions without discomfort.
  5. Integrated MixAmp Pro: The A50 integrates the MixAmp Pro into its charging base, enabling remote control and advanced audio management, while the A40 requires a separate MixAmp Pro purchase for these features.

Wired vs. Wireless Headset

Astro A40 Connectivity:

  • The Astro A40 offers a wired connection, delivering a reliable and consistent link for gamers who prioritize stability and reliability.

wired-connection-a40

Sale
Astro A40
Astro A40
$229.99 −$50.00 $179.99

Astro A50 Connectivity:

  • In contrast, the Astro A50 offers wireless connectivity, providing users with the freedom to move without the inconvenience of cords.

wireless-connection a50

Sale
Astro A50
Astro A50
$299.99 −$57.32 $242.67

Astro A50 Battery and Range:

  • The Astro A50 features a battery life of around 15 hours per charge, although not exceptional, it remains manageable. Additionally, the headset boasts a wireless range of up to 49 feet, enabling users to move freely between rooms without audio disruptions.

battery-a50

The choice between these headsets boils down to whether you prioritize the convenience of wireless audio or the dependable reliability of a wired connection for your gaming or listening needs.

You can find out the detailed video review of Astro 50 here:

VIDEO
Astro A50 Review|Watch Before You Buy
Sale
Astro A50
Astro A50
$299.99 −$57.32 $242.67

Compatibility

Both the Astro A50 and Astro A40 offer compatibility with a range of platforms, including PC, Xbox, Mac, and PlayStation. However, it’s worth noting that to use the Astro A50 with a PlayStation 5, an external adapter is required, which can be obtained from the Astro website for seamless PS5 compatibility.

Controls

Astro A40 Audio Control:

  • The Astro A40 is equipped with an external and versatile Mixamp Pro, featuring digital Dolby surround sound capabilities.
  • This Mixamp Pro allows users to finely adjust audio settings, providing a high level of control over their sound experience.

Astro A50 Audio Control:

  • Conversely, the Astro A50 features a built-in mix amplifier directly integrated into the headset.
  • This onboard mix amplifier provides convenient and immediate control over audio settings.

Astro A40 and A50 Software Control:

  • Both headsets offer user-friendly control through the intuitive Astro Command Center Software.
  • This software simplifies tasks such as muting/unmuting the headset, adjusting sound decibel levels, and fine-tuning frequencies.
  • Additionally, both headsets include common functions like volume control and channel mixing options for enhanced audio management.

Astro Command Center Software

Comfort

Regarding comfort, the Astro A50 offers an advantage due to its wireless nature, allowing users to lean back comfortably during gaming sessions.

While the Astro A40 is slightly lighter than the A50, both headsets feature comfortable ear padding that can be rotated and tilted, ensuring a comfortable gaming experience with no discomfort.

Sound Customization

Both headsets, the Astro A40 and A50, are compatible with the Astro Command Center software, which provides the flexibility to customize presets and sound effects. Users can easily modify EQ presets, fine-tune microphone sidetone levels, and customize streaming audio to achieve their desired volume levels. The inclusion of an advanced equalizer further expands the range of customization options available for these headsets.

Color and Style Customization

Astro A40 Customization Options:

For gamers seeking a unique aesthetic, Astro offers excellent customization options for the Astro A40 headset. The A40 is available in three distinct color schemes:

  1. Black with Blue Accents
  2. Black with Red Accents
  3. X-Edition: Featuring a sporty red design on the headband and earcups with black accents.

Additionally, the A40 features magnetic Speaker Tags, which allow users to choose from special editions or create custom designs when purchasing from the website. These tags can be easily swapped out since they securely snap onto the headset.

Astro A50 Customization Options:

Similarly, the Astro A50 offers customization choices, albeit in a more limited range. It is available in two styles:

  1. Black with Gold Accents
  2. Black with Grey Accents

The Microphone

Astro A40 Microphone:

For gamers who frequently engage in competitive play or online streaming, opting for a separate microphone often yields superior recording and clarity compared to headset mics.

removable-microphone

Sale
Astro A40
Astro A40
$229.99 −$50.00 $179.99

  • The A40 features a removable microphone with exceptional clarity and sound quality, surpassing the Astro A50’s microphone performance.
  • The detachable mic can be conveniently connected to either of the earcups.
  • Acquiring a mod kit for the Astro A40 provides an extra microphone, earcups, and speaker tags.
  • To mute the mic on the Astro A40, a small dongle on the wire allows for easy toggling between muted and unmuted states.

Astro A50 Microphone:

  • The Astro A50 is equipped with a flip-mute microphone positioned on the side of the headset.
  • This microphone automatically mutes when flipped upward.
  • While the Astro A50 mic offers a flatter sound profile than the Astro A40, it incorporates voice isolation to effectively eliminate background noise, ensuring enhanced voice clarity during use.

Weight

Astro A40 Weight:

  • The Astro A40 headset boasts a weight of approximately 370g, contributing to its lightweight design.
  • This feature makes it highly portable and allows for convenient placement on various surfaces, such as tables or shelves.

Astro A50 Weight:

  • In comparison, the Astro A50 is marginally heavier, weighing in at approximately 380g.
  • Despite this slight increase in weight, it remains easy to transport and can be effortlessly positioned on different areas of a table or shelf.

 

weight

Prices

The Astro A50, offering wireless capabilities, comes at a higher price point compared to the wired Astro A40. If your budget allows for it, the added wireless feature represents a worthwhile investment.

Preview Product Rating Price
ASTRO Gaming A40 TR Headset + MixAmp Pro... ASTRO Gaming A40 TR Headset + MixAmp Pro... 2,176 Reviews $394.95
ASTRO Gaming A50 Wireless Headset + Base... ASTRO Gaming A50 Wireless Headset + Base... 4,553 Reviews $299.99 $242.67

Furthermore, both headsets can be further upgraded to maximize their performance. By investing in mod kits, you can enhance various aspects of the headset, including noise-canceling features, speaker tags, a voice-isolating microphone, and padded headbands. These upgrades provide users with a comprehensive solution for tailoring their headset to their specific needs and preferences.

Which Option is Superior: Astro A40 or Astro A50?

The Astro A40 offers a wired connection, ensuring reliability and stability in exchange for a lower price point. It excels in terms of microphone clarity and sound quality, making it a suitable choice for competitive gamers and streamers. Additionally, the A40’s modular design allows for customization through mod kits.

On the other hand, the Astro A50 is wireless, providing freedom of movement and convenience. While it comes at a higher price, the A50 offers an immersive gaming experience with its surround sound capabilities. The microphone on the A50 may not match the clarity of the A40, but it compensates with voice isolation and wireless functionality.

Astro A40 or Astro A50?
Ultimately, if you prioritize a wired connection, microphone quality, and customization options, the Astro A40 is the better choice. However, if you value wireless freedom, surround sound, and convenience, the Astro A50 is the superior option for you.

If you’re still undecided, we recommend watching a detailed video review of both models :

VIDEO
Astro A40 VS Astro A50 - what's the difference between the gen 4s?

FAQ

Do the A40s sound better than A50s?

While the A50 offers a balanced sound profile, its soundstage isn’t as expansive as the open-back A40. Opting for the A40 is a preferable choice if you wish to avoid the constraints of battery life.

Are the A40 and A50 the same?

Astro A50 is wireless, whereas Astro A40 is wired gaming heaset.

Does Astro A50 have a MixAmp?

Yes, the Astro A50 headset typically includes a built-in MixAmp, allowing users to control various audio settings directly on the headset for a personalized sound experience. This MixAmp integration enhances the headset’s audio versatility and user convenience.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the choice between the Astro A40 and Astro A50 gaming headsets depends on your specific priorities. The A40 offers a wired connection, exceptional microphone clarity, and customization options, while the A50 provides wireless freedom, surround sound, and convenience. Make your decision based on what matters most to you: reliability or wireless functionality.

  • Was this article helpful? 0
  • YesNo

Michael Dixon

Michael Dixon

After earning a degree in sound engineering from Full Sail University, I've dedicated my life to the intricacies of sound. Over the years working with giants such as SVS and Harman/Kardon, I have expanded my knowledge and experience. As a tech enthusiast and author, I follow the latest developments and presentations in the gadget industry with great interest. Possessing 13 years of experience in the field of audio technology, I've cultivated a sharp acumen for identifying upcoming breakthroughs in this domain, and I take pleasure in imparting my perspectives to others. My goal is to provide readers with the most accurate and up-to-date information possible, as well as analyze the innovations and trends shaping the technological future.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a comment

Reviews Technology
Logo